No Singing/Praying Zone

The Alliance Defense Fund is suing an Ohio library board of trustees who don’t seem to understand that the First Amendment mentions freedom of religion:

Attorneys with the Alliance Defense Fund filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of Citizens for Community Values Friday after an Ohio library denied the community organization use of a public meeting room. The Upper Arlington Public Library Board of Trustees said the proposed meetings violated library policy because they contained “inherent elements of a religious service.”

“Christian groups shouldn’t be discriminated against for their beliefs,” said ADF Legal Counsel Tim Chandler. “The government cannot treat people with non-religious viewpoints more favorably than people with religious viewpoints. Christians have the same First Amendment rights as anyone else in America.”

CCV requested permission to hold an event at a meeting room available to community groups at the Upper Arlington Public Library. The event is part of a series of presentations being held in Ohio called “Politics and the Pulpit.” The event provides information on the current status of the law with regard to Christian political involvement as well as teaching from the Bible about such involvement. The event also includes prayer and a time of singing and giving thanks to God for the freedom Americans have to participate in the political process.

The library denied the meeting room request, stating that some aspects of the meeting were permissible under the library’s policy; however, singing and prayer were not permissible. A library official wrote that the prohibited activities are “inherent elements of a religious service” and therefore conflict with the library’s policy.

“The government cannot discriminate against Christians or Christian groups simply because they are religious,” said ADF-allied attorney and co-counsel David Langdon of Cincinnati.

This breach of the First Amendment rights of both freedom of religion and freedom of speech are egregious enough so that the federal Justice Department has gotten involved on the side of ADF. You hear about stories like this and you’ve got to wonder what’s going through the minds of the people who make decisions like this. Did they really think they could prevent outside groups from using their facilities because of the content of their speech, or Who it would be directed to? Because they sing? Even the ACLU or Americans United for Separation of Church and States wouldn’t defend actions like this (would they?).
The ADF complaint is here.