Dogs gotta bark, fish gotta swim, and the World Council of Churches has to reaffirm its 1960s-style Marxist heritage from time to time. With the assistance of the World Alliance of Reformed Churches (WARC) and the Council for World Mission (CWM), an interfaith group of totalitarian-lovin’ lefties “theologians, activists, pastors and educators from around the world” gathered May 15-20 for a workshop entitled “Spirituality of Resistance, Liberation and Transformation,” which was held–where else?–in Cuba.
They ended their week by putting out a “communique” that sounds like it was put together by a machine that randomly strings together leftist cliches:
We are in Cuba, a country that approaches the celebration of 50 years of its revolution. Cubans describe the present period as a “Kairotic” passage, a time of crisis and opportunity. The people’s suffering is acute because of the U.S.-imposed blockade and the general forces of empire. By “empire” we mean the complex and dynamic international regime of power anchored by the United States, with its military power, neoliberal globalization, racist and patriarchal ideologies and policies of environmental degradation. In spite of these forces of empire and Cubans’ relentless suffering, isolation and impoverization, we have been inspired by the ways Cubans persevere in struggle, embodying joy and resistance, dignity and self-esteem.
In the present moment, for example, Cubans’ earlier revolutionary successes in agrarian reform have been set back by the empire’s brutal blockade, other international developments, and by tensions within the country. Still, Cubans press forward with ongoing reform, inventively crafting new modes of agro-ecology.
Our meeting in Mazanzas has thus been blessed by having Cuba as a present point of reference throughout all our discussions of the crises of empire. This workshop was originally planned to take place in Beirut, Lebanon. The explosion of conflict there, and the continuing illegal occupation of Palestine by the forces of empire, remind us that this is a Kairotic moment for so many other groups worldwide.
Love that last bit–the reason they didn’t meet in Beirut has nothing to do with the unnamed imperial demon (Israel), but the violence precipitated by their good buddies in Hezbollah. In short, they were worried that their friends might mistake them for target practice.
There’s really no point in trying to take apart this kind of nonsense, whose lefty-babble is so hackneyed and detached from reality that it might have come from the Web site of the Workers World Party. I do find it amazing that at this late date anyone could be so mindlessly adulatory of the island gulag, but then, for some people, it’s always 1968.
The statement then goes on to a collection of equally mind-numbing nonsense about “the multiplicity of spiritualities,” including tripe such as this:
We affirm that the problems of empire, amid which justice movements struggle, are not only political problems but also spiritual challenges. Empire spawns its own destructive spiritualities, such as the “religious right,” and thus it seeks always to co-opt the powers of religion for imperial aims. New spiritualities are coming forth to oppose imperial spiritualities, and these should be supported.
What would a gathering of Marxist theologians be without a swipe at the “religious right”?
Religious groups and all peoples of conscience should recognize a leading role for indigenous peoples, honouring especially their earth-centered spirituality, focusing on interdependencies of body, mind, land, community, and spirit, as resources for a liberating justice for all creation. We affirm the struggle of all First Nations peoples for their land and for their rights to self-determination.
Here we have the obligatory “Christianity bad, paganism good” declaration.
In this time especially, the empire’s worldwide “war on terror” has created a virulent form of Islamophobia that compounds other related racisms. Emergent spiritualities must stand with our Muslim sisters and brothers and work with them for a more just world for all peoples.
And when the people who aren’t engaged in terrorism take over, guess who will be among the first to have their heads on the chopping block?
Then we have their take on Christian spiritualities in particular:
Justice movements challenge Christians to relinquish the hegemony of their Christian language and rituals in movement work, even when this means leaving the comfort zones of Christian belief and practice. New acts of Christian humility and confession – due to Christians’ construction of empire building, colonization, racism and patriarchy – must entail a new collective and variegated spirituality forged from among all peoples, recognizing especially the initiatives of long-colonized and oppressed peoples.
How dare you Christians continue to be Christians! Why, the planet would be a one-world, Muslim-ruled, Jew-free, egalitarian ecotopia without you! Down on your knees and beg forgiveness, you racist, sexist, homophobic, Islamophobic, neo-Nazi, Zionist, capitalist, heterosexist, colonialist, patriarchal (“have we forgotten anything? Oh, yeah…”) Republican pigs!
Christian leaders and institutions, when participating in justice movements, must foster liberating spiritualities by re-interpreting their Christian stories, beliefs and practices to challenge forthrightly the forces of empire.
And stop being so Christian!
According to the WARC Web site, the representative of the world’s Reformed churches was positively inspired by her sojourn in the workers’ paradise:
Patricia Sheerattan-Bisnauth, executive secretary of WARC’s Office for Church Renewal, Justice and Partnership, said the crisis of the times calls for a radical spirituality to energize the covenanting for justice movement.
“Connecting with the struggle, resilience and vision of the Cuban people and the spiritualities of aboriginal peoples and various faith traditions brings fresh impetus in our struggle for justice,” she concluded.
I think there’s really only one appropriate response to all this–take it away, Riff:
May 27, 2008 at 10:27 am
Wow, what a load of crap.
May 27, 2008 at 10:57 am
WARC (C. Kilpatrick, Prop’t'r) is that same even-handed, neutral body which the Stated Clerk of the PC(USA)–C. Kilpatrick, Prop’t'r–plans to ask to adjudge the current unpleasantness in some American presbyterian circles. I just cannot wait to read that report.
May 27, 2008 at 11:33 am
In what sense is the WARC “reformed” and why do we (EPC) remain in the WARC?
May 27, 2008 at 11:41 am
Steve: We actually debated this at General Assembly a couple of years ago. There was an overture to withdraw from WARC that was set aside (I don’t remember if it was withdrawn or defeated) because it was believed we needed to be in WARC to have ties with PCUSA that would make it easier for congregations to move between the two denominations. At this point, I’m not sure whether the WARC connection makes any difference, or if it will after the PCUSA GA. If not, we should definitely get out of WARC, and I expect most if not all EPCers feel the same way.
May 27, 2008 at 11:42 am
Oh, I forgot to add: WARC is only “Reformed” inasmuch as that is one of the words in the organization’s name. Beyond that, I don’t know of anything that would enable it to claim the title.
May 27, 2008 at 12:07 pm
But did they wear their Che t-shirts?
I wonder why they have not actually moved to live in one of these utopias? Hmmmm…
It’s easier to be a Marxist when one has air conditioning and satellite television I guess.
May 27, 2008 at 1:01 pm
I think I just spewed.
May 27, 2008 at 2:45 pm
Ok… theologically, culturally; the whole Rocky Horror Picture show analogy isn’t so far off. Kind of creeps you out, ya know?
May 27, 2008 at 3:39 pm
David
The connection between indigenous peoples and Marxism is because supposedly their lands are tied to them through their spiritualities. So it is communal land ownership. It is a new way of doing Marxism. It also excludes Christians from evangelizing the indigenous groups.
May 27, 2008 at 7:15 pm
I just hope you can vote to get out of the WARC before we vote to have them investigate you.
May 27, 2008 at 11:01 pm
David,
I hate to mention this but one reason that the EPC was in (and maybe the reason they remain in) is that the leadership wanted to be “in between” the churches like PC(USA) and those who (and this is a direct quote of a former Moderator of the EPC) “take this reformed stuff too seriously.” Another reason is that some of the more conservative Reformed groupings would not accept the EPC due to the EPC’s ordination of Females as Ruling and Teaching Elders. (NAPARC).
May 28, 2008 at 10:38 am
Yea, and Cuba’s such a paradise that the Cuban Navy has its hands full trying to keep all the Parrotheads from Key West from trying to ride inner tubes and rubber rafts the ninety miles across the ocean to land on Cuban soil and take advantage of their open and free society.
May 28, 2008 at 12:49 pm
[...] TOTALITARIAN-LOVIN’ CHURCHIES– “Time Warping, WCC-Style” …. [...]
June 1, 2008 at 2:26 pm
Waking from an ideological stupor (UDATED)…
From the Religious Left blogroll, Ravine of Light opens her eyes and sees, perhaps for the first time:As a pacifist by nature and by choice, I struggle with war and the need for it. I want to negotiate with evil…